OS X and Macs - the Windows killer?

For the last week I have almost exclusively been using a PowerPC Mac - claimed by Apple to be a great platform just a few years a ago. Personally, I think that Mac OS X is an interesting platform. The mac hasn't grabbed me.

On the up side, OS X (and Darwin) is based on BSD, so it has some good security foundations, it also uses many tools common to Linux, such as bash and CUPS. The 3D desktop effects are kinda cool for the first day, but then just become part of the day to day experience. I am yet to see a real advantage to the OS X 3D desktop.

The Mighty Mouse is pretty slick. The scroll wheel feels very nice and is well positioned. The side buttons for expose are addictive on the first day. A let down is that you have to change your preferences to enable the right button.

I don't claim to understand the whole Mac software management system, but from what I do know, you drop a disk image (a dmx file) into the applications folder in finder and it is installed. Want to remove it? delete the folder. This is pretty neat, once you understand how it works. It reminds me of the klik package management system.

The file open dialog is a crazy hierarchical beast, that works. Jumping between levels in a tree really works. Pity more than 3 levels down it can involve some vertical scrolling and you need to select a file to get its full name if it is too long.

Now for the downsides of using a Mac running OS X.

The keyboard feels awful, this is one of the times I would recommend a Microsoft product, but as MS keyboard feels far better than an Apple Keyboard. The standard mac keyboard feels plasticy and the key travel doesn't feel right. I have used a range of keyboards over the years and the Max keyboard feels awful. Maye apple should rebrand Logitech's kit, like Microsoft does.

My next complaint is key bindings. For ever since I remember, [home] takes you to the start of current line and [end] takes you to the end of the current line. Many apps even ignore the [home]/[end] keys. Windows, GNOME and KDE all bind [alt] [F4] to close window - but not the mac. There are many other standard combinations ignored by Apple. Another annoyance is the apple key - for most things it functions like a [ctrl] on a PC, but not in a shell, then it functions like an apple key and [ctrl] functions like a [ctrl] key under *nix - I have lost track of how many windows i have closed when trying to delete a word in the console (bash fiends know what i mean).

Inconsistent use of key combinations. In the console and some other apps, [apple] [arrow] loops through the windows of the application, but not Apple Mail, it has decided that the combo expands/collapses message threads, very annoying when trying to compose a message while trying to copy and paste from another.

The maximise button doesn't actually maximise. I am not sure if it is up to the application or the window manager, but clicking maximise (the green circle) may increase or decrease the width or height of the window. When I click maximise, I expect the window to be maximised - or at the very least increased in dimensions.

The real deal breakers for me are the [home]/[end] keys, the inconsistent shortcuts and other crazy behaviour of OSX mean that I won't be switching to a Mac anytime soon.

Over the next week I plan to load more FLOSS on the mac, such as Mozilla Thunderbird for email, which will join Mozilla Firefox web browser and gvim - my referred text editor. I doubt this will be enough for me to stick with OS X.

The indigo iMac G3 I landed last week is likely to be running Copland (a PPC port of xubuntu) real soon now. I am still trying to work out what I do with Julie's Apple Powerbook G3, which currently runs Xubuntu 6.06.1 LTS, as ubuntu has dropped support for PowerPC in feisy. Maybe I can find other PowerPC machines to install Copland or Debian onto :)

I am yet to see how OS X is more user friendly and and easier crossgrade path for windows users than a Linux desktop.

Copland mention

Chris Lees wrote:

I came to your site when I followed a link to your Windows refund story, and clicked around to this link; and then I saw that you mention my project Copland!

Just so you know, there's a bug in Ubuntu's Ubiquity installer that prevents Copland from installing - I'm working on it as we speak. BTW Copland isn't a PPC port of Xubuntu, it's an independent distribution specifically targeted at Macs, which happens to use Xubuntu as a base.

Added Thu, 2007-05-31 00:54

UNIX is the best but windows

Anonymous wrote:

UNIX is the best but windows is defenately better than mac (anyversion)

Added Fri, 2008-08-15 04:13

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <p> <div> <blockquote> <pre>

More information about formatting options

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.